Latest Update:  July 24, 1991

My First Telescope (MFT4)

This expansion of the telescope information is in response to Ben
Medvitz' questions about how to get started making a mirror. Ben, you
also asked whether to make one. Surely, after reading MFT2 and 3, you
should be aware of my feelings on that matter. While I'm not going to
write a complete text on mirror making in this essay, I'm going to add
a few subjects that either aren't in the mirror making books or maybe
I just don't remember them <grin>. Making your own mirror for a
reflecting telescope is the surest way to control the final surfaces:

    You know just how accurate is your Foucault tester and whether it
     is made with a moving pinhole light source or a moving knife
     edge. I commented about the difference between those types in
     MFT2 or 3. Also, you know the constraints you are putting on the
     accuracy of your mirror by how small a division you can read with
     the Foucault tester. That is, whether you are using a
     hand-graduated scale that can easily read 1/64"; can barely read
     1/100"; or if you are using a micrometer readable to 1/1000",
     with which you can make a mirror accurate to 1/20 surface
     accuracy, 1/10 wave front, and with a 1/20 wave surface accuracy
     diagonal mirror, which generates a 1/10 wave front and thus the
     two surfaces give a system accuracy of 1/5 wave; such a system is
     better than most commercial telescopes.

     You can see that such a telescope will bring more of the rays
     from all parts of the mirror to a single focus than the 1/2 wave
     system accuracy 6"f8 that my wife made when she was 16 years old
     and with just Thompson's book for advice. If you can find a
     better micro- meter, such as the one I used that read to half a
     thousandth, you can make a mirror accurate to 1/40 wave surface
     and 1/20 wave front accuracy. Using that with an elliptical 1/20
     wave commercial diagonal, that has a 1/10 wave front, the system
     accuracy is 3/20, giving you a mirror to be proud of
     
    You control the surface quality by taking the time to do it
     right, something a commercial supplier cannot afford to do and
     remain competitive with suppliers with less than perfect mirrors.
     Also you don't get stuck with some manufacturer's 1/10 wave
     surface accuracy, which of course, is 1/5, or for the two mirrors
     of a Newtonian telescope, 4/5 wave system accuracy

    You have to decide anyway about the diameter of the mirror,
     noting that an eight-inch mirror takes about twice as long to
     make as a six-inch and that takes about twice as long as a four
     and 1/4-inch. Also, making an f5 takes perhaps three times as
     long as an f6 and that takes about twice as long as an f8. Any
     item that takes longer to make will cost more if you have to buy
     it.

     If there are no time constraints an 8"f6 or f5.5 or f5 are fine
     and powerful instruments. Note, however, to go below f5.5, you
     have to go to a tool of smaller diameter than the mirror. Doing
     so appreciably extends both the time it takes to make a mirror
     and your control over that mirror's surface. Unless you are being
     advised by someone or have instructions in a book by someone who
     has made a mirror of shorter focus than f5.5, you are better
     advised to make that or an f6.

     You can make a smaller mirror with a long focus to start and show
     you how to do things; a second mirror always goes faster than
     your first mirror. The fastest to finish would be a four and a
     quarter inch f15. At that focal length you can leave the mirror
     spherical. Such a telescope would be considered better for
     looking at the planets; also it would suffer less from
     atmospheric problems than any larger size mirror.

     Don't sniff at such an instrument. My Questar catadioptric is a
     3"f13.5. Probably most telescopes sold around the world, as
     least through 1950, were 3"f15 refractors. I owned a 3"f15
     Unitron refractor, which I traded for a 4"f15 Unitron refractor,
     which I traded for I'm not sure, but I think I said in one of the
     Rambling Thoughts essays that I traded it for a hunting rifle. I
     might comment that there is a brisk market for used telescopes.
     But, as you remember from MFT2 and 3, the quality control of the
     makers of most used--and new--telescopes leave something to be
     desired

    You control the focal length, an important part of the height of
     your telescope's eyepiece. If you can help it, you don't want to
     have to stand on a ladder to look through your eyepiece. Of
     course, if you build a large telescope you need at least a ladder
     or at best an adjustable height chair to observe comfortably

    You decide whether you want to build anything from a short-focus,
     rich-field telescope to a long focus planetary telescope. If you
     decide on the planetary instrument you should look at my Rambling
     Thoughts essays, which is where, I think, I got into that. That
     is, due to the atmospheric disturbances (caused by various
     temperature atmospheric layers traveling at various speeds and
     directions) you mostly want to use a low power, a choice made
     difficult if all you have is a long focus instrument. You can
     always do what I did, that is, for the rare times you can use a
     lot of power, you can insert a Barlow lens in front of your
     eyepiece and double or triple the effective focal length of your
     system.

I want to emphasize that you should use a notebook to keep a record of
what you do while mirror making. I just asked my wife how long it took
her to make her mirror in 1952. She said she doesn't remember, but the
next time either of us comes across the notebook she kept, we'll find
out. I must have had a notebook but it has gotten lost over time. I
know my 10 inch f4 took to the end of 69 hours to rough grind; to the
end of 98 hours to fine grind; it had 8 hours of polishing, after
which it was spherical to 1/20 wave surface accuracy. Of course an f4
can't be left spherical unless a correcting plate were used, to turn
it into either a Schmidt camera (which has no visual focus) or a
Schmidt-Cassegrain catadioptric telescope. I wanted neither of those
designs; I wanted a short focus, rich field, Newtonian-Cassegrain. I
ended up with a Newtonian. Hmm. I guess I ended up with a
Newtonian-Barlow.

Ben, as I mentioned in the cover message, there are little tricks you
can use to speed up your production of a fine mirror. The biggest
time-saver I ever found in the grinding stages is to use the pencil
test. I don't remember seeing this test in the mirror-making books.

What you are trying to do in the last stages of rough grinding is to
get the surfaces of the mirror and tool into contact over the whole
surface. The reason to do that is to ensure that contact, as if they
aren't in contact and you go to the first stage of fine grinding,
there will be no grinding done on the out-of-contact areas of the
mirror and tool. Berry says, I think, that you should look at the
bubbles of water and. . . .

I've seen the bubble method used, but it isn't anywhere as useful as
the pencil test.

"Boy, Don, you sure go on and on and talk around a subject. Do all
teachers do that, or do you have the monopoly on that procedure?"

Grrr. Okay, you are at the last of the rough grinding and you don't
know for sure if your surfaces are in contact. You wash and dry the
mirror and tool and then, using a sharpened #2 pencil, draw parallel
lines, about an inch apart on the tool. Then put the mirror carefully
down on the tool, center over center. Now move the mirror back and
forth--about an eighth to a quarter of an inch--in the same direction
as the pencil lines. Use about 20 lbs. of pressure.

Then you carefully remove the mirror from the tool and examine the now
transferred lines on the mirror's surface. It is unlikely that you
will see them as parallel lines all across that surface. You might see
them all across except in the center or all across except near the
edge. If they aren't visible in the mirror's center, that means you
have ground a hyperbolic surface into the mirror. You are trying to
grind a spherical surface, the only way you can get both surfaces in
contact. If the no pencil hole is in the center it means you have been
making too long a stroke. Put the mirror center over center and grind
using a short stroke.

If the pencil marks don't transfer to the edge of the mirror, it means
your strokes have been too short. Now you need to lengthen your stroke
by taking at least 1/3 to 1/2 strokes. Eventually, using these tech-
niques, you see faint pencil marks all across the mirror. Remember to
record all stroke variations, along with an estimate of the pressure
you are using, and the time you used to adjust your surfaces in your
note- book. If you find your surfaces getting worse instead of better,
you can analyze the procedures you have recorded.

Now you are ready to go on to fine grinding. You started with #80
Carborundum(R), a manufactured product not found in nature on Earth
until about 1990 or 1991, and recently detected in the outer layers of
a star's atmosphere. Each stage of fine grinding erases the pits left
by the previous stage. You use #120, 220, 320, and 400 Carbo. The
final stages depend on what your kit supplier sends you. Of course, a
mirror making group might buy much larger containers of the abrasives,
cutting down the cost to each member. That's what we did in Illinois.

At the end of each stage of fine grinding, which you know by examining
the surface with a 10X magnifier or a one inch f.l. eyepiece and you
don't see larger pits from a previous stage, you use the pencil test
to make sure you are in contact. One way you can know you aren't in
contact is with the magnifier showing you larger pits in the center
(or the edge) than over the rest of the mirror. An out of contact
mirror and tool does no grinding where not in contact. Your focal
length (Well, at least your mirror's focal length.) will vary from
your stated goal if you always grind with the mirror on top.

You can check your mirror's focal length during the fine grinding
procedures by wetting the mirror's surface, mounting it on the mirror
holder, a device that uses a wooden back in which are two dowels,
mounted at a slight upward angle, on which the mirror sits facing you.
That vertical piece is mounted on a flat horizontal board, so the
mirror can't tip over. A clip at the top of the vertical board holds
the top of the mirror.

In an otherwise dark room, you aim a flashlight at the mirror. The
flashlight should be next to your head. As the head and light source
combo move from right to left, and the image of the light reflected
from the mirror also moves from right to left, you know you are inside
the focus. As you don't use parallel light, like from a star or our
local star, our sun, the focus will be at twice the goal you are
shooting for. As an example, if you are making an 8"f6, the focal
length is 48" but the center of curvature during the flashlight test
and later, during the Foucault test is at 96".

As you move from right to left and the reflected image moves from left
to right, you are outside the center of curvature.  As you move from
right to left and the image seems to be coming from all directions at
once, you are at the center of curvature. You mark that distance in
your notebook, for reference. If it is at 93" and your goal is an
8"f6, the focal length is too short and you continue your grinding,
with the mirror face up on the bottom and you work it over with the
tool. Obviously, if the center of curvature is too long, you continue
with the mirror being worked over the tool.

Eventually it all comes out right, with the center of curvature where
you want it, with the pencil test showing you are in perfect contact,
and with no pits larger than the ones you are grinding into the
surfaces with the present grade.

The final stage of fine grinding should be done with cement dust.
While some writers specify emery as the substance of choice, in my
opinion they haven't used cement dust. Cement dust cuts down the size
of the remaining pits (from the previous stage of fine grinding) by
3/4. It's use saves much time in the polishing stages.

   --by don rosenfield, asst. general sysop/cosmogonist/telescope nut:
                       an honorable calling
                       All Rights Reserved
