Latest Update:  July 17, 1991

RAMBLING THOUGHTS by a cosmogonist, Number 14

The following message, to me from Walter Clark, and my response to him
is surely worth membership in the hierarchy of Rambling Thoughts.
Walter was going to give an opening remarks presentation at the June
meeting of the OCA. He asked me to comment on the subject of Olber's
paradox. That theory tries to explain why the sky is dark at night.
Perniciously [I] probably passed [to him the] pertinent precise prose
[on the] paradox.

From:   Walter Clark
To:  Donald Rosenfield

I didn't have time to describe Olber's paradox.  Isn't there a theory
that even if you have a uniformly dense universe, infinite in extent,
and timeless, the sky would be mostly dark owing to what
mathematicians call one infinity being larger than another [?]  If you
have a ratio (area of sky vs. area of star surface) and you let them
both become infinity AT THEIR OWN PACE you will find that their ratio
does not necessarily go to infinity or zero. Zero over zero is said to
be undefined. That doesn't mean it is undiscussable. Likewise whatever
the ratio of stars to black in a given volume of space, as it grows
that ratio stays about the same.

If that isn't a theory, I'll claim it. The Clark solution to the
Olber's paradox.

My reply follows:

Walter, you made a couple or three  major points in your Message 426.
Chris looked at your message. Her sole comment was that infinity
divided by infinity is undefined as well as zero divided by zero. Your
second point was about the, " . . .uniformly dense universe, infinite
in extent, and timeless . . .

Are you aware that you are discussing the interior of a black hole? As
all mass there is at its Schwarzschild Radius, that mass is uniform.
As there is no way out nor a way to see out, that mass is infinite
(for those inside). And timeless? There is no time, just as there is
no space, (That is, there's no spacetime.) inside a black hole
Universe. Another aspect, that you comment on, above, is about
darkness in such a place. You better believe it, buddy. There is no
light inside a black hole.

The parameters of a black hole include that matter or energy entering
the event horizon of the hole do so at light speed. At light speed
anywhere --whether going into a black hole or just traveling to
another solar system--the Einstein modified Lorentz-Fitzgerald
equations kick in. Thus your mass becomes infinite, your length in the
direction of travel becomes zero, and (your) time stops.

Do you know that there is a theory that our Universe is inside a black
hole? It is my understanding that, in spite of your comment--your last
point--that the ratio of stars to black in a given volume of space, as
the system (Universe, section of a Universe, whatever) grows that
ratio stays constant, is not a true statement. It is however,
consistent with Fred Hoyle's discredited Steady State theory.

Perhaps it is constant for a time and then the blackness grows, in an
Entropic Universe. With no new matter or matter converted from energy
in the supply bin, the stars will tend to burn out--or, at least, burn
down, so what you get is white dwarfs gone to seed . . . er, ah,
cooled to red dwarfs, then to brown dwarfs, then to black dwarfs. That
applies whether we have a Big Bang Universe, in which we have the
exploding Ylem about 20 billion years ago and the expanding Universe
never stopping expanding or one or another of the varieties of an
Oscillating Universe.

Balloons can't continue to be blown up indefinitely. There comes a
time when they burst. What would prevent the fabric of space from
being torn apart--with the Big Smash being generated by the collapse
of a mixture of galaxies, their components, the intergalactic
material, and torn pieces of space fabric? That implies that the
correct theory is one of the flavors of the Bang Bang theory.

In the Big Bang Universe, at first you wouldn't have anybody saying
anything about a dark sky, there not being any dark skies, or for that
matter, anybody to say it, what with the temperature of the
surroundings many millions of degrees Clark. (I would use Kelvin's
name, but he isn't born yet in your Universe.)

Then, as the system grows, evolves, and cools you would begin to see
blackness. Don't be confused by the possibility of seeing blackness or
anything else at all on the other side from where the Ylem exploded;
there is no other side; spacetime not existing at the Ylem.

However, if you have an Entropic Universe, where the Second Law of
Thermodynamics operates, we don't live in the same place. My Universe
is Antientropic, as I develop in Chapter 15 of my manuscript, which
you deigned not to read.
                                                         
   <There's> a thought. You live in an Entropic Universe and I live in
an Antientropic Universe, with both Universes interfacing between
Anaheim and Fullerton. The interface, for some reason, is called 91.
Your time is going forward and mine is going backward, though that
isn't discernible by me. Your computer breaks down due to entropy. My
computer will never break down. Your spacefabric is expanding, mine is
contracting. Our <now> is the same. You kept forgetting and so you put
hydrogen in your schwarz, which is why all your schwarzes blew up. We
both see antipimples (gravity wells). There is no way of telling which
Universe you are in.

   Always remember the importance of not putting hydrogen in your
schwarz.  Hold back the antipimples.

--by don rosenfield, asst. general sysop/cosmogonist/black hole dipper
                            All Rights Reserved
