Latest Update:  January 7, 1992

RAMBLING THOUGHTS by a cosmogonist, Number 28

"I don't understand something, Uncle Don. All your life you shied
   away from writing essays and, until you got your Apple computer,
   nearly everything else. We hardly got letters from you. Now
   there's a nonstop flood of essays, nonews letters, book manu-
   scripts, messages on Prodigy and other BBSs. . . .How will it all
   end? Is there a glimmer of hope that in the future you might stop
   writing? Will we be spared further damage from this overflow of
   words you're throwing at us? Don't bother to answer this; just
   think about it."

Hmm. There's an easy way to stop the flow:  just take away my
   computer

"While I've got your attention, Uncle Don, I've been meaning to ask
   about the ridiculous ads like the one by Tele Vue on page 7 of the
   January 1992 _Astronomy_ magazine. "Genesis Owner Turned Into
   Zombie!"  The author of that letter to the manufacturer about the
   high quality of his 4" apochromatic refractor (three-lens
   telescope)  said it showed objects that his 8" Schmidt- Cassegrain
   (SC) couldn't see.

"I don't have trouble with that, following your discussion in MFT2-3
   and RT1-4 about the inability of the 8" and other size SCs to bring
   many, if not most, light rays to a focus, due to the accuracy (!)
   to which they are figured, in relation to the price charged for
   them. I suppose they make quality control decisions on the basis
   of marketing research; any more accuracy would come at a greatly
   increased labor cost, resulting in prices beyond the reach of most
   amateurs. In your comparison of your 3.5" Questar with an 8" SC,
   you showed the Questar was superior.

"No, my problem is with the price of the three-lens vs. the two-lens
   refractors. Once you have ray-traced the design of either a two or
   three-lens refractor, why would the three-lens design cost so much
   more than the two-lens design? It doesn't make sense! Sure, the
   third lens in the telescope costs more if it's made of fluorite,
   but does it cost five or ten times as much as the rest of the
   telescope?"

I wouldn't think so. Apochromats were made long before fluorite
   lenses became available. I'm not sure of what, but I would guess
   they were made of flint glass. Ordinary achromatic (two-lens)
   refractors are made with a front lens of crown glass, which has one
   index of refraction and a rear lens of flint glass, which has the
   opposite index of refraction. The idea behind that design is to
   bring as many of the blue and red light rays to the same focus as
   is possible. Not all *can* be brought to the same focus, so all
   achromats have a faint blue or red milieu (to coin a new meaning
   for that word) around the image.

So I suppose that a third lens would also be of flint glass (if
   fluorite wasn't used). It would correct for the chromatic
   aberration which was a resultant of the other two lenses. However
   there's a trade-off. There's *always* a trade-off. The third lens
   would absorb some of the light impinging upon it. Also, now you
   have three lenses that have to be ground, polished, and figured.
   That's six surfaces to contend with, plus either a prism or mirror
   star diagonal. If a prism is used, you have nine surfaces total.
   If a mirror is used, you have seven surfaces. Compare that with a
   Newtonian reflector that has but two mirror surfaces, and, assuming
   you use adequate oculars, no chromatic aberration.

I don't know to what accuracy Tele Vue makes their lens surfaces. If
   it is 1/10 wave, then using a prism diagonal, the resultant system
   accuracy is one full wave! That takes the six lens surfaces plus
   the entrance, to and fro on the reflecting surface, and exit of the
   prism or a total of ten x 1/10 = 1 wave. Using a mirror diagonal,
   you get a system accuracy of 8/10. Compare those with the
   Questar's system accuracy of 1/8 wave.

If Tele Vue makes their surfaces to 1/20 wave, the prism diagonal will
   be accurate to half a wave and a mirror diagonal to 2/5 wave.

"You're saying, I see, that you get what you pay for and know about.
   If you expect a magnificent telescope for a high price and after
   paying that high price you don't get a magnificent telescope, who's
   to blame but yourself? By reading and paying attention to these
   discussions on accuracy you are in a good condition to get what you
   want. You must find out from the vendor all the specifications
   outlined above and in the other RTs noted above."

             --by don rosenfield, asst. general sysop/cosmogonist
                            All Rights Reserved
