Latest Update:  February 6, 1992

RAMBLING THOUGHTS by a cosmogonist, Number 30

FROM   : KEITH BROWN                  RECEIVED : YES
TO     : DONALD ROSENFIELD            PRIVATE  : NO
SUBJECT: Mirror Making                THREAD   : YES

Well, I decided to start with a 6" f/8 because I've heard that its a
good place to start. Not very far from spherical. Besides, I own a 6"
f/6, and I thought it might be good to try out an f/8. I am hoping to
learn enough by doing a simple project to someday tackle a light
bucket.
 
    +=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+
A 6"f8 with a 1/2" ocular magnifies 96X. With a 3X Barlow lens, it
 magnifies 288X. You can magnify that much perhaps 10 nights a year.
 The 6"f6 with the same setup magnifies 216X. That might serve you 15
 nights a year.

Those two instruments are too close together in capabilities for you
 to have them in the same house! Perhaps you could mount a 6"f12 on
 your f6 mounting. Used mainly for planetary observations on the few
 nights a year that have steady atmospheric conditions, a 3X Barlow
 and a 1/2" ocular gives 432X. Perhaps that combo could be used 3 or
 4 times a year. Using a 1" ocular without a Barlow, you get 72X, a
 1/2" gets you 144X.

An f12 has so few nights usable few people make them. I know,
 thousands of refractors have been made at f15. But the best seeing
 with them came with 1-1/4" to 2" oculars. So their purveyors sold
 them with 1/4" oculars? Ha! Hee hee!

If you decide to make an f12, please ignore the books that say you can
 leave it spherical. You can't leave it spherical and expect to bring
 all the light rays to the same focus. You still have to parabolize
 it. Keith, you said in your message that you wanted to make an f8
 because it wasn't far from spherical?

Using the Foucault test, a sphere has the apparent cross-section of a
 flat line. A parabola has the apparent cross-section of a doughnut.
 The difference between the rays reflected from the center of the
 parabola and from the edge derive the formula r square /R (using a
 fixed light source). All you have to do is keep in mind (and keep
 smooth) that cross-section and measure when those rays get to the
 distance of that formula from each other.

No, I don't think you should do the 6"f8. It won't give you the kind
 of training you want to prepare yourself for making a light bucket,
 most of which are f4s or f5s. It is *much* more time-consuming to
 make a mirror whose focal ratio is shorter than f5.5 than to make one
 that or a longer focal ratio. That's why the 100" Hooker telescope
 on Mount Wilson *is* an f5.5.

The reason is that when you go shorter than f5.5 you have to use both
 your head bone and a tool smaller in diameter than your mirror in the
 mirror making process. But when you go to a shorter focal length you
 get a wider field of view, longer eye relief, steadier images (with a
 given ocular), etc. If you were starting from scratch and told me
 you wanted to make a 6"f8 I would have suggested a 6" or 8" f6. But
 as you already have the f6, you should make an f5 and in a larger
 size. An 8"f5 or a 10"f5 would be an excellent mirror to train on
 for later triumphs.

In my book I have a table showing telescope diameters vs. numbers of
 stars. With a 6" you can see 5 million stars. An 8" will show 8
 million stars and a 10" will show 13 million stars. Why go to all
 the work of making a mirror that won't show you anything you can't
 see with your present instrument?

"Yeahbut, Uncle Don, maybe his 6"f6 isn't of top quality. Maybe he
 got it from some outfit that advertised +\- 1/4 wave! (Any newcomers
 reading that sentence should read MFT2-4 and RT1-4, with additional
 material in the rest of the RTs.)  With a 'scope like that, he can't
 bring all the light rays to the same focus and his spherical
 aberration would be a wonder to see. That would give him the
 incentive to make a superb 6"f8, after which he could refigure the f6
 to make an effective mirror."

Yeah Audrey. You got me there. I don't know the quality of his f6.
 *He* might not know its quality. There are a lot more poor mirrors
 in use than good ones.

By the way, Keith, I've never met the person who runs the OCA mirror
 making group. I keep referring people to him. I never hear what
 happened with them. I hope he's not a purple people eater . . . .

             --by don rosenfield, asst. general sysop/cosmogonist
                            All Rights Reserved
