Latest Update:  July 25, 1992

RAMBLING THOUGHTS by a cosmogonist, Number 38

The "Gleanings for ATMs" on page 684 of the June 1992 issue of _Sky &
 Telescope_ gets into the bright idea of a flat-headed screw being
 epoxied onto the back of a spherical (or other nonparaboloidal)
 mirror and then, using a wing-nut, stressing the mirror into a
 paraboloid.

"Wow! That's a *great* idea, Uncle Don! No more will we have to
 slave over oil drums."

Hold on a bit there, Audrey. What makes you think you won't have to
 slave. . . .Where do you think you are going to get a spherical
 mirror good to 1/40 wave?

"What? Well I'm sure optical companies, those now selling finished
 mirrors will supply them."

Where will they get them? It takes darn near the same time to make a
 1/40 wave (1/20 wave front) sphere as it does a 1/40 wave with
 another specific curvature. Remember that a 1/40 wave surface
 accuracy on the two mirrors of a Newtonian generates a 1/10 wave
 system accuracy.

When I made my 10"f4 it was spherical to 1/20 wave (surface accuracy)
 at the end of polishing. How did I know that? How would you know
 the accuracy of your measurement when you make (or buy) a wing-nut
 mirror?

If your tester can measure to 1/1000" and the apparent cross-section
 of your mirror under test is flat, then your mirror is accurate to
 1/20 wave surface accuracy or 1/10 wave front. If your tester can
 measure to 1/2000" (as discussed in the MFTs) and the apparent cross-
 section is flat, your mirror has a surface accuracy of 1/40 wave and
 a 1/20 wave front.

In the case of my 10 inch, my tester could reach 1/40 wave and there were
 some defects on the surface; however as a whole it tested as a sphere
 within 1/20 wave. The Foucault tester measures the difference in
 depth between two areas on the mirror. It might be easier to make an
 elliptical mirror, one you can measure. Then you just stress the
 mirror with the wing-nut a different amount than you stress a sphere.

All the other constraints I note in the MFTs and the early RTs obtain
 here. If you buy a commercial telescope with wing-nut figure
 adjustment you must still know what the surface accuracy or wave
 front of the components is. You certainly don't want a wing-nut
 mirror figured to a 1/4 wave or 1/10 wave surface accuracy. As in
 every step of telescope design and optical production, whether bought
 or made by you, you have to know what you are doing. That's what I
 have tried to instill in you with this series of essays.

"How would you use a wing-nut mirror in a catadioptric telescope?"

That's a good question, Audrey. You can't use it in any telescope that
 requires a hole in the center of the mirror. I suppose that if it were
 important for you to have such a telescope you would use a Nasmyth
 design.

That design is one where the light passes through the correcting
 plate, to the main mirror--that has no central hole for the light to
 pass through--to the secondary mirror and then to a tertiary mirror,
 this one flat, that sends the light to the side of the telescope
 where you put your eyepiece or camera mount.

Some telescopes with four-meter diameter mirrors are being made with
 the Nasmyth focus sent through the altitude bearings (on an alt-
 azimuth mounting).

As a forerunner to this next sequence of messages, I had been signing
 off with, "May the next Ylem not come in your lifetime," (or words to
 that effect) and was surprised that nobody questioned me on that. Of
 course, that just applies to newcomers on our board. I discussed
 Ylem in RT13. As with many of the questions we get nowadays, many of
 them have already been discussed in the RTs, in File Area [U]:

==========================================================================
FROM   : ROB MATSON                             RECEIVED : YES
TO     : DONALD ROSENFIELD                      PRIVATE  : NO
SUBJECT: Ylem                                   THREAD   : YES

Actually, I've been wondering about it since I first saw it a week ago 
or so in one of your old messages! But, I figured it was something you
had been using for a long time, and that everyone BUT me knew what it 
meant, so I didn't want to appear to be "out of it"! (Sort of like
Rush Limbaugh rookies who occasionally ask what "dittos" means...)  So, 
I give -- what's Ylem. Sounds bad from your connotation -- anything
like an earth-crossing meteoric impact?

=================================================================
FROM   : DONALD ROSENFIELD                      RECEIVED : NO
TO     : ROB MATSON                             PRIVATE  : NO
SUBJECT: Ylem                                   THREAD   : YES

Before Ye Grande Olde Bang popped its cork, all the material that
 makes up our Universe was in one place, first at Planck-size, which
 is 10 to the -33 of the size of a hydrogen atom, then about a
 millimeter in diameter, then the size of a (hollow) bowling ball, and
 then it exploded to its greatest expanse. After that our Universe
 started slowing, visible with a telescope-equipped spectrograph. Now
 all the groups of galaxies--such as the one we belong to, the Local
 Group--are closing in on what is called the Great Attractor (GA).

Ylem is the name for everything that existed after the last Smash and
 before the Big Bang. It is the name for what will be extant after
 the next Smash, which has now started.
  
I predicted the existence of the 147 million light years distant Great
 Attractor two years before it was discovered, in my Chapter 15, "The
 Ultimate Illusion" in _Astronomy For The Love Of It_.
  
"Wait just one flippin' nanosecond there Mister! How do we know our
Universe started slowing that long ago?"
  
Oh, that's easy to see. The most distant objects we can detect are
 not as far away from us as their velocities indicate. That is, their
 redshift is blueshifted from the position on the spectrograph in
 comparison with the redshifted position if they had not started blue-
 shifting (slowing).
  
"I don't like where this discussion is going. <Careful, tiny, mincing
steps> Tell me more about the Great Attractor."
  
All the groups of galaxies on the other side of the GA are rushing
 towards it. All the groups of galaxies on our side are also rushing
 toward it. (In case a Brit reads this, "toward" is American
 spelling.)
  
Our Local Group is rushing toward the GA at 600 kilometers per second,
 in the direction of the Hydra-Centaurus supercluster, which itself is
 moving that fast away from us.

A finding in 1986 was that there are 20% more galaxies near one side
 than the other side of our observable Universe. For about three to
 four years following those studies there were some misgivings about
 the GA.

That was because we could detect galaxies falling into the Great
 Attractor from this side only. Then, in January of 1990, came the
 announcement that galaxies this side of the Great Attractor are being
 drawn to it and those 160 million light years or further were being
 drawn towards it and us. The diameter of the area receiving the
 inflow of galaxies is measured as 300 million light years.

As I develop in my theory, light only travels on the surface of the
 fabric of space. We can see the galaxies as millions of light years
 away and yet crash into them in the next Big Smash without warning.
 
May Ylem be after your lifetime,
  
Donald
====================================================================
FROM   : BOB HOLTZMAN                           RECEIVED : NO
TO     : DONALD ROSENFIELD                      PRIVATE  : NO
SUBJECT: RT14 Message                           THREAD   : YES

You're right, of course, about the 20 billion year estimate. Although
it seems that every time someone finds a more distant object, the 
estimates must be revised further back in time. I've been looking for
a copy of what I wrote, and can't seem to find it in the mess on my 
desk. However, why wouldn't 20 billion years be sufficient time in a
universe where the rate of expansion is decreasing, if black holes are 
growing at an increasing rate? Yes, I'll read your RT19 message, as
soon as I can figure out how to access it.

FROM   : DONALD ROSENFIELD                      RECEIVED : NO
TO     : FRANK SNIVELY                          PRIVATE  : NO
SUBJECT: ylem                                   THREAD   : YES

Well, I don't think I need you to call it, " . . . your Ylem."  George
 Gamow named Ylem after the ancient Greek term for the primordial
 stuff from which the world was born. Gamow also coined the term,
 "Big Bang," to describe what happened at that beginning.
  
That was what I got from one source. Another source noted in a
 footnote says that Fred Hoyle coined the term, "Big Bang" to
 describe--derisively --Gamow's theory.
  
One of my major points in my manuscript is that the Big Bang cannot
 have happened the way current theory says it did. I go into flights
 of fancy theory explaining why not.
  
May Ylem not come in your lifetime; if that is shorter than mine, may 
 it not come then, either,

==================================================================
FROM   : DONALD ROSENFIELD                      RECEIVED : NO
TO     : BOB HOLTZMAN                           PRIVATE  : NO
SUBJECT: RT14 Message                           THREAD   : YES

BH> . . . it seems that every time someone finds a more distant object 
the estimates must be revised further back in time.
  
Hmm? We judge our Universe is 20 billion years old. That figure has
 stood for a pile of years. At the limits of our instruments there is
 a cloud of soupy gas that was the newly formed Universe before it
 separated into the galaxies. We see nothing more distant than that.
  
I think it was early in the 80s, after the CCDs became rampant and we
 could reach 28th magnitude, that the comment was made that even if
 our telescopes improve we wouldn't see objects further than we can
 already see. Of course, after that statement our telescopes *did*
 improve and we found the zillions of blue and red galaxies located
 about 17 billion light years from us.

We can see more details about what we'd already detected and we can
 see new objects our previous equipment can't reach; however, all is
 within our 20 billion light year diameter Universe. mmH
  
--by don rosenfield, asst. general sysop/cosmogonist/ylem slayer
                            All Rights Reserved
