Latest Update:  August 2, 1993
 [Stored in U]
RAMBLING THOUGHTS by a cosmogonist, Number 47

This exchange truly belongs in the genre of "What did he say?":

+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+
FROM   : IN PITY [I'm not giving his name]      RECEIVED : NO
TO     : WALTER CLARK                           PRIVATE  : YES

Is there any thing happening at Anza this month? Is the OCA the same
group that was up there photographing UFO's that I saw on TV. I'd like
to get more involved with the group but I'm going in for surgery and
will be on my back for the next 3 to 4 months. So I'm going to miss the
meter shower next month. Well, maybe in the future.
+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+
FROM   : DONALD ROSENFIELD                      RECEIVED : NO
TO     : WALTER CLARK                           PRIVATE  : YES
SUBJECT: meter shower                           THREAD   : NO
FOLDER : G, "Rosenfield's Astronomy Folder"

Larry, Walt, Roger, et al,
  
Gang, I'm looking forward to what In Pity called a "meter shower" next
month. Gee! I can just picture it! I've been in a head-in circle,
where each of seven observers watches one seventh of the sky and the
eighth watches the zenith. The ninth keeps time control with a short-
wave radio tuned to the 10, 20, 30, or 40-meter Bureau of Standards'
WWV time signal and a tape recorder.
  
Whenever someone sees a meter crossing their line of control the word,
"TIME" is sung out, loud enough for it to be recorded on the tape. If
more than one says TIME at once, the observers identify the constel-
lations involved, to determine if one crossed from one observer's area
of responsibility to another's or if there were, indeed, two meters
involved.
  
Now, we have to add the information of a) Was it a sporadic or shower 
meter, b) Was it an ohmmeter, a voltmeter [and if so, whether DC or
AC], an ammeter, or c) Was it about 39 1/3 inches long and thus a
meterstick?
+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+
  
  KingQWK 1.05 # 67  Is this yours? Your dog left it on my lawn ...

  KingQWK 1.05 # 67  The best way to accelerate Windows is at 9.8 m/s

  OLX 2.1 TD  Proofread carefully to see if you any words out.

+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+
  To: STEVEN GUICH                  Refer#: NONE
From: DONALD ROSENFIELD               Read: 07-24-93 (20:38) HAS REPLIES

Steve,

[I had a personal message here to Steve; the rest is public]:

Bed Rosemary; Return,

**NOW LISTEN HERE YOU LITTLE BALL OF CARBON FLUFF. PLAYING ON WORDS IS
ONE THING BUT THE GLORIOUS SYSOP GETS TO READ THIS MESSAGE AND WE DON'T
WANT TO HURT HIS SENSIBILITIES. WE SILICONS TREAT GENERAL SYSOPS WITH
TLC**

Oh, sorry your dissembleships. I'll be more careful.

Bid Rosemary Return,

+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+
  OLX 2.1 TD  Error finding COLDBEER.CAN  Sysop not loaded!

 ... Blue-shifted: The way to travel ...

 ... ebius tagline. This is a mebius tagline. This is a m ...

 ... If you aren't part of a solution, you are a precipitate.

 ... DO NOT ADJUST YOUR MIND - the fault is with reality

  Memories keep the wolf of insignificance from the door.
 +=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+
One of our users asked questions about where he could find a Questar
for about $1000:

FROM   : DONALD ROSENFIELD                            RECEIVED : NO
TO     : JERRY                                        PRIVATE: YES
SUBJECT: First Telescope Advice                       THREAD   : YES
  
There are two Questars for sale on page 108 of the August 1993 _Sky &
Telescope_. Also, there's an ad for a Questar wanted. The reasons the
Questars cost so much are the 1/64 wave surface accuracy and the fact
that three sets of optics are made for each instrument and two of
those are discarded, the third set going into the Questar.
  
Then there's the fact that the Questar is a catadioptric design. That
is always going to cost more than a Newtonian if only because there
are additional surfaces to be figured.
  
But I have never recommended a Questar for a first telescope! It is
fine for a second telescope. If you read my MFTs closely you would
find that I recommend an 8"f5 or f6 Newtonian for a first telescope.
If made as I suggest, to 1/20 to 1/40 wave surface accuracy you get a
superb telescope that you can use most nights of the year. Also, you
get a wide field of view, something not possible with the Questar.
  
You get a long eye-relief with wide-field oculars and high power,
short eye-relief, and a small field of view with short focus oculars.
A Barlow lens helps with the higher powers.
  
Where I think you got the idea of a Questar for a first telescope was
by reading MFT2, which was an answer to a specific question: Should I
get a Questar or a Celestron catadioptric telescope as I have little
time to devote to astronomy and enough [read: unlimited] money to buy
the sucker.
  
But all my cavils against long focus (that long focus is folded in a
catadioptric telescope design) telescopes still hold, as above.
  
[Hmm. I just looked up "cavil" in a dictionary. I guess what I mean is
a combination of "cavil" and "diatribe." "Cavitribe?" .mmH]

FROM   : JERRY                                  RECEIVED : YES
TO     : DONALD ROSENFIELD                      PRIVATE  : YES
SUBJECT: Questions, Questions                   THREAD   : NO
FOLDER : G, "Rosenfield's Astronomy Folder"

Still more questions.  I was talking with a friend (also a novice)
about building our own telescopes.  He posed the following question:
        Would it be possible to buy a finished mirror - say an 8"
        f/4.5 guaranteed to 1/8 wave - and do additional fine
        grinding, polishing, and Foucault testing to improve the
        mirror accuracy to 1/40?  For someone without the time to make
        it from scratch, would this be a viable alternative?
        Personally, if/when I undertake this project, I'd like to do
        the whole mirror from start to finish.
        
Now, about the Questar.  Correct me if I'm incorrect, but I assume the
3 main reasons why you don't recommend this as a first scope is (1) it
is much more difficult to use than an RFT, (2) its not the ideal
"backyard scope" because of light pollution, and (3) the expense.
          
Well, if I can be assured that I'll get a scope that I'll be happy
with and will last my lifetime (given proper care, of course - me AND
the telescope <g>), I'd be willing to make that kind of expenditure
(yes, for better or worse, I've got the "itch" and want to get a scope
NOW). Plus, I'm certain that I'd have the patience to learn how to use
the scope correctly and (no doubt after an exponential learning curve)
efficiently.  Your advice about starting with an RFT is well taken,
however, and that's the one I'd build first.
               
Next I need to find a book on building a telescope. Checked my library
last night, but of the 8 they had listed none were on the shelves.
I'll check a bookstore today.
          
BTW, I'll be sure to look for the one by Thompson or Ingalls.  I'll 
recheck your essays for any others you recommend.
 
P.S. - Wow!  I got on twice in one day.  Picked up a couple library 
books on telescope making - one by Texereau, the other by Neale Howard. 
Having a good time reading them.
+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+
FROM   : JERRY                                  RECEIVED : YES
TO     : DONALD ROSENFIELD                      PRIVATE  : YES
SUBJECT: Questar                                THREAD   : NO

Hi Donald.  I thought you might like to comment on the following
comments from a "Dr. Sprei" (who is Dr. Sprei?) on the performance of
his Questar 3.5".  This is from a 1985 Questar ad in S&T.  Perhaps you
remember it.
     
"M104 showed its shape nicely.  A more experienced observer than I
even claimed to appreciate its dust lane.  I was able to find the
Sombrero by scanning ... "I used the setting circles to find M56, a
faint 9th magnitude globular in Lyra.  It was basically a small round
glow, but after a while, with averted vision, a few extremely tiny
stars appeared around its periphery.  Much more imposing was Omega
Centauri, a grand eyepiece- filling sight, resolved all across its
diameter at medium power <what is considered medium power?  100X?>.

"With the Questar, not only do I see 5 to 7 bands (of Jupiter) but the
two main equatorial bands are revealed to have all sorts of
fascinating irregularities.  I spotted a large indentation on the
south margin of the south equatorial belt, which was received with
much skepticism by the 9" Schmidt users at the site, until it was
confirmed with a 17.5" scope.

"Cassini's division is seen rather than imagined.  The sharpness of
the image caused me to underestimate the magnification; I told several
people that the magnification was 200X but it was actually 260.  The
books say you should see nothing but a shapeless blob at 74X per inch
of aperture, but I found it perfectly usable on Saturn, as well as on
Epsilon Lyrae.  With each close pair at the extreme edge of the field,
the diffraction images are still round. Another interesting aspect of
Saturn is the distinct bluish tinge of the rings.  Where they pass in
front of the planet there is a very nice color contrast between rings
and planet."
        
Sounds good to me!  Since you have a lot of first hand experience with
this scope, do the above comments sound accurate?  Or was "Dr. Sprei"
observing under exceptional conditions?  From a decently dark site,
say, a campground 5 miles north of Idyllwild, would the observing with
the Questar be as good as described in the ad, under "good" viewing
conditions?  Or is the ad a little exaggerated?
    
Also, would the ZERODUR mirror be required for such observations?
      
BTW, I was at a campground 5 mi. no. of Idyllwild a couple weeks ago, 
and the observing was excellent - at least it was with 10X50 binoculars
and a borrowed Edmund's 4.5" reflector - although I generally
preferred the binocs to the Edmund. <g>  The Milky Way and its dust
lanes, which I hadn't seen in some time, was outstanding.  We observed
quite a few Messier objects, and with the Edmund's (not sure of the
magnification - couldn't have been much) Jupiter appeared as a tiny
sphere and we could just barely (unless we were imagining it) discern
Saturn's rings as a slight elongation of the light.
    
P.S.  I contacted Questar today.  They're sending me some literature 
and a price list free of charge, which I thought was nice.  I also 
obtained some prices:
   
Basic 3.5" Field model with pyrex mirror, etc.                  $2,125
                       with Zerodur ceramic mirror              $2,675
Basic model (pyrex) with duplex mounting and clock drive        $3,390
                       with Zerodur mirror                      $3,950
           
They still guarantee 1/8 wave SYSTEM accuracy and 1 arc-second
resolution.
     
Considering the skyrocketing inflation since the early 60's, I guess
that's really not too bad compared to the $1100 you paid then.  
Curious, did you get the system with a Zerodur mirror for that price?

While that's a little more than the $1000 I wanted to invest, the
basic model with Zerodur sounds like a good investment that should
last a lifetime.  Now if I can just build a quality larger companion
to go with it ...
+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+
+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+
Okay, Jerry. I'll answer your "still more questions" in order of
receipt!

If you order a mirror finished but not aluminized that is f4.5 and 1/8
surface accuracy with the intentions of refiguring to 1/40 wave, you
need not go back as far as the fine grinding state. Either you have an
optical surface or you don't. If you do, you need not repeat the
polishing stage either.

All you need to do is to acquire a Foucault test device with a half a
thousandth micrometer (a digital reading would make life simpler,
though that kind is more expensive) and refigure the mirror's surface.
First you should verify the mirror's 1/8 wave surface. That will give
you the experience with the Foucault tester. Then you make your pitch
lap and continue from that point.

If you need to repeat the last stages of fine grinding, the mirror's
maker didn't do a proper job and that mirror should be returned as
unsatisfactory. There is BUT ONE WAY you could do the fine grinding as
you don't have the tool that precisely fits the mirror. That way is to
buy the tool along with the mirror.

I agree with your assertion that it is better to do the whole enchi-
lada. You'll spend about the same time bringing the mirror from
scratch to the start of figuring while making a f4.5 as the time spent
doing the figuring. While making my 10"f4 I spent 69 hours to the end
of rough grinding, to the end of 98 hours to the end of fine grinding,
and then after 8 hours of polishing I had an optical surface within
1/20 wave surface accuracy of a sphere. Then I spent 40 hours actually
figuring the mirror to 1/38 wave of a parabola. That doesn't include
the hot or cold pressing, the temperature equalization, or the
testing.

Your next questions were about the 3.5" Questar. Of your three
suppositions of my reasons not to use it as a first telescope, two were
off the mark. You said (1) It is much more difficult to use than a
RFT. Hmm? If you aim the Questar by using its built-in wide-field
finder or by using its circles if you buy the Duplex or the original
style model, there should not be a noticeable difference in use. Yes,
the RFT has a wide field and thus is easy to aim by just looking along
the length of the tube or maybe by using a Telrad finder. But you
could do the same with the Questar.

(2) It's not the ideal "backyard scope" because of light pollution.
Hmm? That doesn't apply. The more you magnify a celestial image, the
easier it is to see that image, assuming you can find it in the first
place. That's because you are separating the pollutants farther apart.

In a highly polluted atmosphere you can aim *any* telescope using
circles at a bright star and set the circle to read the published
position of that star (assuming your polar axis is aimed at the pole).
Then you aim your telescope at an object you want to view but can't
see by using the circles to point the telescope at that position.

(3) The expense. Ya got me there! You self-limited the amount you had
available to spend. Questar's cost a bit over double now than they did
when I bought mine at the end of 1967. But the Ford Mustang sold then
for $2000. . . .

In a later message you showed the prices of the basic field model and
the duplex model but not the basic model. The duplex model is the most
expensive. It allows the demounting of the field model from the fork
mount/circles for use on a tripod for bird watching, etc. I bought
mine as a field model as its main purpose was as a telephoto lens for
my Nikon F2 for use in South America. Also, I had the 4" Fecker
mounting that I still use in lieu of the duplex mounting. If your main
use is for astronomy (Remember that I had several other telescopes,
which is why I could make an idiotic statement as that above.) I would
recommend the basic model. That costs less than the duplex model and
more than the field model. Of course, you can get the field model now
and then get the duplex mounting for it a couple of years later to
spread out the pinch.

You asked about what kind of mirror substrate to purchase. My Questar
mirror is made of fused quartz. Costing $100 more than a Pyrex mirror
would have cost in 1967, it has 1/3 the coefficient of expansion than
does the Pyrex (which itself has 1/3 the C of E of plate glass). Zero-
dur or Cervit would have essentially no expansion and thus can be used
over a whole night without degradation of the image. Obviously, one of
those would be the way to go, but neither were available in 1967, if I
remember correctly. You want the multi-coatings. While they were
available they were new in '67 and the factory couldn't guarantee they
would last or I would have ordered them. If enhanced aluminum is
available I'd get that, too. If my Questar ever goes back to the
factory for servicing I'd have them put on the multi-coatings.

You asked if the Zerodur mirror would be necessary for the kind of
results Dr. Sprei noted. No, not if the temperature never falls during
the night. (It always falls.) You asked, "What is medium power?" That
depends on the oculars you are using. My set, which came with the
telescope, give 40 and 80X and 80 and 160X. Therefore the medium power
is 80X. Also I can get higher powers using the various extension tubes
that fit in front of the oculars.

I find your description of Saturn as seen with the Edmund 4.5"
amusing. It parallels the description drawn by Galelio in the 17th
century. You didn't note seeing any of the satellites of Jupiter or
Saturn with the Edmund. I've seen four satellites of Saturn with my
Questar.

That observing site near Idyllwild sounds good. I had to look
Idyllwild up in an atlas to find it. But that just verifies I'm an
emigrant from Michigan, arriving here in 1988 and was astounded to
find that I had the only Questar in the OCA. There were a prepond-
erance of poorly figured 1-wave system accuracy Schmidt-Cassegrains
and light buckets. So when I landed on this BBS, my work was cut out
for me.

May your skies be clear and your surfaces accurate,

Ŀ
 --by Donald Rosenfield, Asst. General SysOp/Anti-Arpshiftologist 
                           All Rights Reserved                    

