Latest Update:  June 1, 1991

RAMBLING THOUGHTS by a cosmogonist, Number 9

   "Uncle Don, you keep calling yourself a cosmogonist and I don't
know what a cosmogonist is."

   Okay, Audrey. Anytime you want to break into what I write and make
either cogent comments, to tell me that I'm writing jargon, or to ask
questions, please do so. All cosmogonists in the world except me call
themselves cosmologists. Some of those who call themselves
cosmologists, of course, are cosmologists. The Britannica Dictionary
says that cosmogony is, "A theory of creation, as of the world or of
the universe." It says that cosmology is, "The general science or
philosophy of the universe."  Some cosmogonists (who don't know that's
what they are) are: Carl Sagan, Issac Asimov, Heinz Pagels, and Steven
Hawking. I'm sure you can add to that list.

   In my 550 page manuscript--desperately looking for a publisher, if
not for Susan--with the working title, _Astronomy For The Love Of It_,
I add one black hole theory to the four in the literature, explaining
how all of them work. A subject I'm eternally confused about is why
their authors don't explain how they work. In my Chapter 15, titled
"The Ultimate Illusion," I have two major improvements on the Bang
Bang Bang theory of the evolution of  our Universe--mine are called,
the "Bang Smash Bang theory" and the "Bang Smash Zap Bang theory."
Thus I am certainly qualified to call myself a cosmogonist.

SIMPLICITY

   "Wait a second there, Uncle Don. I thought the major theory was the
Big Bang theory. What's with this Bang Bang Bang stuff?"

   Okay, I'll answer simple questions like that . . .

   "Simple? You call the Big Bang theory simple?"

BANG

   Sure! Anything you know about and chew up and down and sideways and
into the trees while you improve it gains a certain flavor of
simplicity. The Big Bang theorists state that sometime around 20
billion years ago, all the matter and energy in our Universe was in
one small place, about a millimeter or so in diameter. Then it grew to
a few inches in diameter, with the configuration of a hollow bubble.
It had a temperature in the billions of degrees Kelvin and could have
lasted but a few seconds before it exploded.

   I should add that some important cosmogonists, Steven Hawking, for
example, say our Universe is only (!) 10 billion years old, but I
don't understand how he comes up with that figure, as most of the
stars in the globular clusters are 15-18 billion years old, the most
distant quasars are about 15-17 billion years old, and some faint blue
and red galaxies found recently are (possibly) about 17 billion years
old. Of course, if his billion is the same as our trillion, then he's
saying our Universe is only 10 trillion years old and that's too long
a time. For one thing, there is some evidence that we can see all the
way around our spacetime and there's no way that can allow a 10-
trillion year old Universe.

__________________________
NOTE:  In RT6, RT7, and above, I said that the stars in the globular
clusters range up to 18 billion years. But Vincent Kiernan in his
article: "Cosmology:  How Far to the Galaxies?"  _Astronomy_, June
1989, pp 48-54, says that those cluster stars range from 14 billion to
20 billion years old. He doesn't give his source for those figures.
The 20 billion year figure puts the globulars older than our Milky Way
galaxy and right on the ages since the Grand Olde Bang. Nowhere else
have I seen anyone saying that the globulars are the same age as our
Universe. __________________________

   It is impolite to ask what the conditions were that developed into
those extant in the Big Bang theory. To continue:  Time started. Our
Universe started its expansion, which is still going on. The galaxies,
clusters of galaxies,  and superclusters of galaxies formed. The
stars, star clusters, nebulae, etc., formed.

   The first generation of stars, often called metal-poor stars,
contained barely anything but hydrogen, a bit of helium, and maybe a
smidgen of lithium. They operated by the fusion reaction that takes
place in all stars (those massive enough)--four atoms of hydrogen fuse
to become two atoms of helium and give  off energy in the form of the
heat, such as we get from our sun. (We also get cosmic radiation,
infrared radiation, x-rays, etc. from our sun and other stars, but
that isn't necessary to answer your question.)

__________________________
NOTE:  Another couple or three of things I'm not getting into are the
white dwarf stars, the neutron stars, and the pulsars. Those objects
have to modify my statement above about all stars operating with the
fusion reaction. Like the novae, they are covered in my book.
_________________________

   After the helium developed in the cores of the stars and conditions
there got so hot that the helium started to fuse, forming heavier
elements yet, some of the more massive of the stars exploded, what is
called a supernova. I realize that I'm not explaining ordinary novae,
but I suspect my audience doesn't want this to get more complicated
than I have to make it.

   In the intense reactions that occur in a supernova, heavier yet
elements formed and seeded the surrounding nebular clouds, which had
themselves been made of hydrogen. Some stars got old without
exploding, because their mass wasn't high enough. The mass necessary
to go supernova is 3.2 or more times the mass of our sun. In the stars
of less mass then, fusion reaction can go up until the formation of
gaseous iron.

   Now if one of those iron stars were to be in a close double star
(called a binary) arrangement with a less massive star, the less
massive component of those can lose matter to the more massive star.
(Fifty percent of all stars we can see naked-eye are double or
multiple stars. The figure rises to about 75-80 percent if you include
those discernible by telescopes and spectroscopes.)

   If, after the iron star rises to a mass of at least  3.2 times that
of our sun, that star were to supernova, the  surrounding nebula gets
seeded with all of the 92 elements we can detect on our sun. That kind
of well-seeded nebula is an example of what formed into our solar
system 4.61 billion years ago.

   An interesting datum is that 6 billion year old diamonds have been
found in Zaire. They were formed in the supernova that seeded our
generative nebula, an interesting way to date that supernova. All the
atoms and molecules in your body, Audrey, were manufactured in and
came from that massive star when it went supernova. Don't feel that
you are special due to that circumstance. Every living thing, down to
the single cell animals and plants and bacteria and viruses have atoms
and molecules formed in that supernova--or those supernovae. Now,
Audrey, I see you are going to sob again. I didn't really mean it when
I said you weren't special.

   As I said, the time from the Big Bang, which by the way--before the
Big Bang explosion--is called the Ylem (May the Ylem be with you.), is
20 billion years. Under that theory, our Universe will continue to
expand forever. Few astronomers accept the Big Bang theory.

BANG BANG

   The second flavor of Bangs is the Bang Bang theory. With that one,
there is a Ylem 20 billion years ago, time starts, along with the
Bang, the expansion and formation of the galaxies and so forth begins
and, after 40 billion years starts to contract after which there is a
Big Crunch or Big Smash--depending on who's work you are reading--and
time ends. That's all there is, folks; there ain't no more. It is
impolite to ask what happened before the first Bang or what happens
after the second. Again, there  are  few astronomers/cosmogonists/
philosophers who accept the Bang Bang theory.

BANG BANG BANG

   The Bang Bang Bang theorists say that there was a Ylem, the last
one being 20 billion years ago, when time started; our Universe
expands for another 20 billion years, contracts for 40 billion years,
has a time stopping Big Smash, which forms the Ylem which starts time
up again and expands. That procedure is followed time after time. As
entropy always increases, we will eventually use up the energy and the
last Bang will be a whimper.

   When or how the first of that series of Bangs started is an
impolite question. The granddaddy of impolite questions was the
ancient Hindu question. They knew that the world was held on the backs
of three elephants standing on a turtle. The turtle was standing on a
snake (which was eating its tail) and it was impolite to ask what the
snake stood on.

   As I said, the Bang Bang Bang is the most widely accepted theory.
But, around 1973 I became dissatisfied with it. In an astronomy course
I was teaching at Oakland University, I was giving the seminar on all
the kinds of theories on the evolution of our Universe then extant.
But when we got to the Bang Bang Bang I had a sudden insight and
continued on with a differing theory, one that was an anti-entropic
Universe, one whose energy doesn't run down. My students were sitting
there with their mouths hanging open, as they realized I had intuited
an improvement on the Bang Bang Bang right in front of them.

   "Boy, Uncle Don. I'm glad you aren't writing this stuff using math-
ematical descriptions. I wouldn't be able to follow you. I guess your
experience teaching junior high school science prepares you for
projects like this that you can explain in a manner that anyone can
understand."

   Thanks for the kind words, Audrey. I taught both junior and senior
high school, as well as community college, university classes and
adult education programs. In addition to those, I was Director of the
Delta College Planetarium, (in Michigan) having K-12 students from
three counties come to me in addition to the college kids and adult
church and social groups. Also, the clinical psychological interviews
I did in Brazil--in Portuguese (for my dissertation) were among second
and third graders. Ya know, I might get to my research there in a
later RT, because my dissertation was on the application of
developmental psychology to the teaching of astronomy in a
planetarium. As it worked out, I compared 400 years of Sao Paulo's
city development with the city's view of the increasingly polluted
skies.

BANG SMASH BANG

   Back to where we were, my change in the Bang Bang Bang was that it
was circular, that the first one hadn't happened yet. The BBB that
other astronomers accepted didn't seem to take into consideration that
spacetime is curved, so the BBB sequence must also be curved. I had
that theory, which I called the Bang Smash Bang theory published in an
astronomy newsletter in Michigan, and sat back to wait until my theory
got shot to pieces. No potshots were ever taken.

   A friend of mine writes childrens' stories. I showed her the
article explaining Bang Smash Bang and asked her how I should improve
it. She said to put it away and every once in a while take it out and
something will come to me. Well, I did that for about eight years,
with not much happening. I had gone as far as I could with that
theory.

   My Bang Smash Zap Bang theory came about when I started to write a
book about astronomy. It answers all the parts of other theories that
itch the mind, including: the shape of our Universe, time reversal, 11
dimensions, the fabric of spacetime, quasar generation, black holes
and white holes--what they are and what happens to them, etc. Also,
the theory answers the impolite questions of what happens before and
after a Ylem. Obviously I'm not going to describe in a message file
what takes 72 pages to explain in the manuscript, which now is on its
64th draft.

   Always remember the importance of not putting hydrogen in your
schwartz.

 --by don rosenfield, asst. general sysop/cosmogonist/putative author
                          All Rights Reserved
